Adapting recipes is one of my hobbies. The other day, it was too hot to turn on the oven, yet I needed a cool dessert for an office potluck lunch. Enter: SunButter®, in the Frozen SunButter Pie recipe. I also wanted to gather my colleagues’ impressions of the flavors and textures.
This dessert was quick and easy to make, affordable and got rave reviews. Best of all, it was simple to adapt.
Layering the whipped topping into a graham cracker crust
Adaptations: Those sensitive to possible allergens in the graham crust could do this without the crust in a pie dish or in 6 – 8 individual dishes (great for kids, who would each get their own serving). The layers turn out pretty in a clear glass sundae dish.

Spreading on the jam
Adaptation: I used raspberry because fresh raspberries are now in season. You could use any jam or jelly that you and your family prefer. What sweet berry flavor doesn’t go with the slightly salty flavor of sunflower seeds? One colleague noticed the texture of the raspberry seeds didn’t quite jive with the sunflower seeds sprinkled on top. Next time, I’ll try jelly or a fruit spread without seeds.

Blending the SunButter® and cold milk, then instant pudding mix and whipped topping
Adaptations: I used vanilla pudding mix, but was tempted by the cheesecake flavor.
Some pudding mixes and whipped toppings do contain milk, so if that’s an allergy concern, look for mixes or whipped toppings that are milk-free.

Filling the SunButter® pie
Adaptations: We did eat this frozen, so it was refreshing. It would also be good as a cream pie after an hour or so in the refrigerator. I topped it with fresh raspberries and sunflower seeds. You could drizzle on other flavored syrups as well. Careful to read the allergen labels. It would be pretty with a sprig of mint or candied cranberries, depending on the season and occasion.

Taste testing SunButter Frozen Pie
“It’s good.”
“I don’t like SunButter plain, but this is tasty.”
“Mmmmmmmm.”
“It’s very different but delicious.”
“Not too light; not too heavy.”
Affordable nut-free dessert
I spent $17.80 on ingredients for the SunButter® Frozen Pie. I still have nearly-full jars of the jam, SunButter® and sunflower seeds. (I ate the rest of the fresh raspberries while the pie chilled.) To me, that’s a fair value. And I have happy office-mates who were good sports putting up with me adapting yet another recipe.
We’d love to hear your SunButter® recipes. How do you adapt recipes? What have you created lately?